What Insurance Should Property Managers Require?
Common insurance requirements property managers set for vendors, with a table by trade (handyman, plumber, HVAC, roofer, janitorial and more).
Property managers commonly require every vendor to carry commercial general liability (often $1 million per occurrence and $2 million aggregate) and workers' compensation, with auto liability for drivers and higher limits or an umbrella for high-risk trades like roofing. Requirements are a contract choice, so confirm limits with your insurance agent and attorney.
If you manage 50 to 500 units, you probably have a plumber you have used for ten years, a handyman someone's cousin recommended, and a janitorial company on a month-to-month deal. Each one is a way for a bad day at your property to become your problem. This article covers what to ask each of them to carry. For the day-to-day review process, see the property manager COI compliance checklist, and for the full picture see the COI tracking hub for property managers.
Why Do Property Managers Require Vendor Insurance at All?
Because when a vendor's employee is hurt in a unit, or a vendor floods the unit below, the injured person or the owner of the damaged property will look for anyone with money. Often that includes you and the property owner. A vendor with real coverage, and your company listed as additional insured, means their insurer responds first. A vendor with no coverage means the claim lands on your owner's policy, and eventually on your management agreement.
A scenario that plays out regularly: an uninsured handyman repairs a water heater connection on a Friday. On Sunday it fails and soaks two units. His "company" is a pickup truck and a phone number. Everyone's insurer, and the owner's deductible, now absorbs the loss. A certificate collected in advance would have cost you ten minutes.
What Are the Core Coverages to Require?
- Commercial general liability (CGL). Covers bodily injury and property damage the vendor causes to others. Common ask: $1 million per occurrence, $2 million general aggregate.
- Workers' compensation. Covers the vendor's own employees. Required by statute in most states once a business has employees, with rules that vary. Ask for statutory limits and employer's liability, commonly $500,000 or $1 million.
- Commercial auto. Needed when the vendor drives to and between your properties for the job. Common ask: $1 million combined single limit.
- Umbrella or excess. Adds limits above GL, auto and employer's liability. Typical for roofers, large landscaping and anyone doing work at height.
- Specialty coverage. Pollution liability for pest control, janitorial bonds for cleaners with key access, professional liability for design-oriented trades.
What Are Common Requirements by Vendor Type?
The table below shows limits many property managers use as a starting point. These are common, not mandatory, and your owner agreements, lender requirements, or state rules may call for more. Have your insurance agent review them against your own program.
| Vendor | General liability | Workers' comp | Auto | Often added |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Handyman | $1M / $2M | Statutory, or documented exclusion | $1M if driving | Check for a "handyman" class that excludes roofing or electrical |
| Plumber | $1M / $2M | Statutory | $1M | Umbrella; check for water damage exclusions |
| Electrician | $1M / $2M | Statutory | $1M | Umbrella; proof of license |
| HVAC | $1M / $2M | Statutory | $1M | Pollution coverage for refrigerants, umbrella |
| Roofer | $1M / $2M, often $2M per occurrence | Statutory (confirm roofing is not excluded) | $1M | $2M+ umbrella, higher-risk class |
| Janitorial | $1M / $2M | Statutory | $1M if driving | Janitorial bond or crime coverage for key access |
| Landscaper | $1M / $2M | Statutory | $1M, plus trailer or equipment | Umbrella; pesticide applicator coverage if applicable |
| Painter | $1M / $2M | Statutory | $1M if driving | Check lead-paint exclusions on older buildings |
| Pest control | $1M / $2M | Statutory | $1M | Pollution or pest applicator coverage |
| Locksmith | $1M / $2M | Statutory | $1M | Crime or bonding because they handle keys and access |
For trade-specific detail, see our pages on plumbers, HVAC, electricians and roofers. We cover handymen in a separate guide and cleaners in the janitorial requirements guide.
What Endorsements Should You Ask For Besides Limits?
Limits are the easy part. The wording that protects you is in the endorsements:
- Additional insured for your management company and the owner entity. See what additional insured means and the landlord-specific guide.
- Waiver of subrogation on general liability and workers' comp. See waiver of subrogation explained.
- Primary and non-contributory wording, so the vendor's policy pays before yours.
- Notice of cancellation to the certificate holder, understanding that many carriers will not guarantee it. This is one reason tracking expirations yourself matters.
How Do You Set Tiers Without Overcomplicating It?
Two tiers is enough for most 50 to 500 unit portfolios. Tier one is the baseline above for routine work: handymen, painters, cleaners, locksmiths. Tier two raises limits or requires an umbrella for roofing, major plumbing or electrical, tree work, and anything done on a commercial or mixed-use building. Write both tiers on one page, attach it to your vendor agreement, and note which tier each vendor is assigned.
Also decide your exception rule ahead of time. For example: who can approve a lower limit, and for how long. Exceptions that live in someone's head become the gap you find after a claim.
How Do You Enforce the Requirements Once They Are Written?
Collect the certificate before the first job, not after. Our vendor onboarding workflow covers how to collect them, and the expiration tracking setup guide covers renewals. You can send the request with our vendor insurance request email template.
Software helps here because the requirement rules are checked automatically. In COI File you configure your requirement rules, vendors upload their certificate through a magic-link portal, AI extracts the ACORD 25 fields, and each certificate is checked against your rules. Renewal reminders go out at 30, 14 and 7 days. You can start with a 7-day free trial.
Frequently Asked Questions
Related Resources
Firdaosh Bano
COI Compliance Specialist
Firdaosh Bano is a COI compliance specialist and the founder of COI File. She spent 6 years managing vendor compliance for commercial properties - tracking 2,000+ COIs across 150+ properties in spreadsheets before building the tool she wished she'd had. She writes about certificate of insurance compliance, vendor risk management, and making insurance tracking less painful for small teams.