What If a Vendor Won't Send You a COI?
A vendor stalling on a certificate of insurance? Use this practical script for property managers: what to say, who to call, and when to walk away.
If a vendor won't send a certificate of insurance, ask for their insurance agent's contact details and request the certificate directly from the agent, set a firm deadline in writing, and hold the work until it arrives. If they still refuse, stop using them for your properties and document the decision.
This is one of the most common friction points for a small property management team. Nobody wants to lose a plumber who answers the phone at 9 p.m., but a vendor who will not prove coverage is asking you to carry their risk. Below is how to handle it without burning relationships. For the front-end process that prevents most of these standoffs, see the vendor onboarding COI collection workflow, and for the bigger picture see the property manager COI tracking hub.
Why Do Vendors Stall on Sending a Certificate?
Before you assume bad faith, work out which situation you are in. They tend to fall into five buckets:
- They do not know how. A one-man handyman business may never have been asked. They think "insurance" means the card in the glovebox.
- The agent is slow. The vendor has coverage but the agent takes days to reply, and the vendor is embarrassed to chase.
- They are between policies. A renewal is pending or payment lapsed, and they hope you will not notice.
- Their coverage does not meet your limits. They hold $300,000 and do not want to say so.
- They have no insurance. They are hoping the question goes away.
The first two are fixable in a day. The last three are the reason you ask.
What Should You Say When a Vendor Pushes Back?
Keep it factual and non-personal. It is a requirement for every vendor, not a judgement of them. Three short scripts that work:
First ask. "Before we schedule the work, we need a certificate of insurance showing general liability and workers' comp, with [Company Name] listed as certificate holder. Your insurance agent can email it to us directly. It usually takes a few minutes on their end." You can adapt our vendor insurance request email template.
When they say they have it but can't find it. "No problem. Who is your agent? If you give me the name and number I will contact them directly."
When they say it's too expensive or unnecessary. "I understand. Every vendor working on our properties has to carry coverage, since a claim could otherwise land on the property owner. If you can get it in place we are glad to keep working together."
What Is a Reasonable Escalation Ladder?
| Step | Timing | Action |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Day 0 | Written request with the requirements sheet and a deadline |
| 2 | Day 2 to 3 | Follow up by text or call, ask for the agent's contact details |
| 3 | Day 5 | Contact the agent directly, copying the vendor |
| 4 | Day 7 | Pause new work orders and tell the vendor why |
| 5 | Day 10 to 14 | Mark the vendor non-compliant and remove them from the approved list unless an approved exception exists |
Adjust the timing to your own business. What matters is that the ladder is written and applied evenly, so a long-time vendor is not treated differently from a new one without a recorded reason.
Why Go Straight to the Vendor's Insurance Agent?
Agents issue certificates all day and can generate one in minutes. They can also tell you things the vendor will not: whether coverage is active, whether the policy has a cancellation pending, and whether your required endorsements can be added. A short, polite email to the agent with your requirements often solves the problem the same day. Once you receive it, check it against the requirements using our guide to verifying a certificate of insurance.
When Is an Exception Reasonable?
There are real situations: a burst pipe at midnight, a lockout, a failed boiler in January. A workable rule is a documented emergency exception with four parts: who approved it, what work is covered, a deadline for the certificate (for example, within 3 business days), and a stop rule if the certificate does not arrive. Ask your attorney whether to add any acknowledgement language for the vendor to sign.
What is not reasonable is an open-ended "we'll get it later" for a vendor who is on site every week. For more on what happens when coverage is missing, read what happens when vendor insurance lapses.
When Should You Walk Away?
Walk away when the vendor cannot name an agent or carrier, refuses after two follow-ups, provides a certificate that does not match what the agent says, or tells you directly that they do not carry insurance and do not plan to. A discount does not offset the risk of a bodily injury or water damage claim on an uninsured job. Record the decision and tell the person who handles work orders so the vendor does not quietly get dispatched anyway.
How Do You Stop Having This Conversation Every Month?
Move the request out of your inbox. In COI File, vendors get a magic-link upload page, so there is no account for them to create. AI extracts the ACORD 25 fields and the certificate is checked against your requirement rules. Renewal emails go out at 30, 14 and 7 days, and you can have the vendor's broker copied and escalated if the deadline passes. You can import your vendor list by CSV and try it with the 7-day free trial.
Frequently Asked Questions
Related Resources
Firdaosh Bano
COI Compliance Specialist
Firdaosh Bano is a COI compliance specialist and the founder of COI File. She spent 6 years managing vendor compliance for commercial properties - tracking 2,000+ COIs across 150+ properties in spreadsheets before building the tool she wished she'd had. She writes about certificate of insurance compliance, vendor risk management, and making insurance tracking less painful for small teams.