What Insurance Should a Rental Handyman Carry?
Common insurance requirements for a handyman working on rentals: general liability limits, workers' comp for sole proprietors, exclusions, and COI checks.
A handyman working on rental properties should commonly carry commercial general liability of at least $1 million per occurrence and $2 million aggregate, workers' compensation if they have employees, and auto liability if they drive for the job. Check the policy's exclusions and confirm limits with your insurance agent and attorney.
The handyman is the hardest vendor to insure properly and the easiest to hire without checking. He is cheap, fast, and does a bit of everything: drywall, a faucet, a door lock, a ceiling fan. That "everything" is what causes trouble. This guide is written for a manager with a few handymen across 50 to 500 units. For the broader vendor picture see what insurance property managers should require from vendors and the property manager COI hub.
What Coverage Does a Rental Handyman Actually Need?
- General liability. Responds if the handyman damages the unit, the building or a neighbour's property, or injures a resident. Common ask: $1M per occurrence, $2M aggregate.
- Workers' compensation. Covers employees or helpers. Sole proprietors are treated differently from state to state.
- Commercial auto. Applies if he drives a work truck between properties. A personal auto policy often excludes business use.
- Tools and equipment. Usually his own concern, not yours, but it can matter if he leaves materials in a vacant unit.
Does the Handyman's Policy Cover the Work You Are Giving Him?
This is the question most managers skip. A handyman policy is written for a described class of work. Many carriers limit it to small repairs and exclude certain trades or heights.
A scenario: your handyman patches a roof leak because the roofer is booked for two weeks. He falls, or the patch fails and the unit below floods. His carrier reviews the claim and finds roofing is excluded under his classification. The certificate looked fine. The coverage did not respond. Your owner's policy ends up fielding the claim.
The fix is to treat the certificate as a starting point. Ask the handyman or his agent to confirm in writing which work is covered, and keep a short written list of what he may and may not do for you.
What Work Should Stay Out of a Handyman's Scope?
| Task | Handyman OK? | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Drywall patch, paint touch-up, door adjustment | Usually | Low-hazard, within most handyman policies |
| Faucet swap, toilet repair | Often, check scope | Water damage claims; some policies limit plumbing |
| Hardwired electrical, panel work | Check state rules | Often requires a licensed electrician; common policy exclusion |
| Gas lines, water heaters | Usually use a licensed trade | Fire and explosion exposure; licensing rules |
| Roof, gutters at height | Usually use a roofer | Fall risk; often excluded or surcharged |
| Anything involving lead paint or asbestos | No | Pollution exclusions; specialized licensing |
Use this as a conversation starter with your insurance agent and attorney, since licensing and coverage rules differ by state.
What About Workers' Comp for a One-Person Handyman?
A handyman who works alone may not be required to carry workers' compensation in your state. The risk is what happens when he gets hurt anyway, or when he brings a helper "just for the day." Managers handle this in different ways: require comp for everyone, accept a signed exclusion or independent contractor acknowledgement where the state allows, or only use handymen with coverage. Pick one rule with your attorney and apply it consistently. The same issue shows up with the waiver of subrogation requirement, covered in this guide.
What Should You Check on the Handyman's COI?
- The named insured matches the person or business you contract with.
- Policy dates are current, and you have recorded the expiration.
- General liability limits meet your standard.
- Your company and the property owner are listed as certificate holder, and additional insured if you require it. See certificate holder vs additional insured.
- Description of operations mentions or does not conflict with the work you assign.
- Workers' comp is either shown or the exclusion is documented.
Our guide to reading an ACORD 25 walks through where each item sits on the form.
How Do You Keep Track of Several Handymen?
Handymen change insurers often because their policies are short-term or paid monthly, so certificates go stale faster than a plumber's. Log each policy's expiration date, ask for renewals ahead of time, and confirm that the policy is still active when you are paying an invoice. If your list is long, see COI tracking for small property management companies.
COI File reads the ACORD 25 with AI extraction, checks it against your requirement rules, tags vendors by property, and sends renewal emails at 30, 14 and 7 days. You can import your current handymen by CSV. There is a 7-day free trial if you want to test it on your own vendor list.
Frequently Asked Questions
Related Resources
Firdaosh Bano
COI Compliance Specialist
Firdaosh Bano is a COI compliance specialist and the founder of COI File. She spent 6 years managing vendor compliance for commercial properties - tracking 2,000+ COIs across 150+ properties in spreadsheets before building the tool she wished she'd had. She writes about certificate of insurance compliance, vendor risk management, and making insurance tracking less painful for small teams.